Google has released a FAQ on automatically-created assets (ACA) and marketers are weighing in. As generative AI tools become more prevalent in the marketing industry, understanding their proper usage and benefits is crucial. ACA can save time and provide more relevant ads, leading to increased conversion opportunities. However, marketers are advised to closely monitor and review the assets created by ACA to ensure they align with their brand’s goals and guidelines. Despite the advantages of ACA, human-created assets still outperform automatically-generated ones. Overall, marketers should view ACA as a supplement rather than a replacement to their existing assets.
Google shares ACA FAQ
Ginny Marvin answers common questions about ACA
Google has addressed the most commonly asked questions it receives about automatically-created assets (ACA) and provided some much-needed answers.
Why we care. As more generative AI tools become available to marketers, choosing the right one can be challenging. The confusion about these tools and their proper usage adds to the complexity. Understanding the capabilities of features like ACA can empower marketers to make informed decisions on whether to incorporate them for optimizing their campaign performance.
Google addresses ACA confusion
Ginny Marvin, Product Liaison at Google, used her X account to answer some of the most commonly asked questions her team receives about ACA:
What’s the point of ACA?
“When you enable automatically-created assets at the campaign level, it will create headlines and descriptions for your RSAs. The main goals are to help you save time and provide incremental conversion opportunities with more relevant ads.”
How are ACA used?
“RSAs can assemble ad combinations that are predicted to perform best using both the assets you’ve provided and automatically generated assets.”
Where does ACA pull content from?
“Automatically created assets are generated from your own content, including your landing pages, existing ads, and keywords. Tip: Be sure your website is up-to-date when using this feature!”
Where can I see automatically-created assets?
“ACA will be labeled as ‘Automatically created’ in the ‘Asset source’ column in ad- and campaign-level asset reporting. You’ll also see when ACAs are included in Combination reports.”
Can I remove ACA?
“Yes, you can review & remove assets you don’t want to serve anymore. In addition, any automatically created assets with a ‘low’ performance rating get removed, well, automatically.”
Can I test ACA in Campaign Experiments?
“Yep! Draft and Experiments are compatible with ACA. You will see automatically created assets on both the test and control arm, however, the control side will serve 0 ACA impressions.”
Should I just rely on ACA?
“ACA should augment, not replace, your existing assets. Keep the assets you’ve already created and continue to provide as many as you can (up to 15 headlines and 4 descriptions). Note that ACA don’t count toward these asset limits.”
Marketers give their verdict
Thomas Eccel, SMX Next speaker and Senior Performance Marketing Manager at Jung von Matt IMPACT, advised that while ACA can be a great source of inspiration, this feature needs to be closely monitored. He told Search Engine Land:
- “RSAs can work in my opinion to get inspiration of which Headlines and Description Google think could be potentially driving conversions for my account.”
- “I would not blindly activate them on all accounts: do not activate them for accounts with high brand-control or for accounts where only some specific texts and wordings are allowed.”
- “If activated, I would advise to closely monitor the asset creation and the sense of texts to not find surprises.”
Sarah Stemen, MBA, paid search expert and board member of the Paid Search Association, also shared her findings regarding ACA after experimenting with them in beta:
- Risk awareness: “I got client permission before we tested this (whenever you are testing something like this NEVER test this without making the risks very clear to ALL stakeholders, everyone MUST be on the same page).”
- Monitor daily: “These are indeed pulled from the website which means if you are running a sale on the website a headline will be pulled! If this is a short term sale you risk this headline or description running until the asset is removed by Google so YOU need to monitor this.”
- Headline issue: “The platform will generate headlines longer than the rules (I see this as an advantage).”
- ACA can be boring: “I know, I know we complain that the automatically created anything is ‘bad’ but during the time we tested this in our account +95% of the assets were harmless. Mostly the assets were boring.”
- Human created assets win: “None of the automatically created assets performed better than the human-created assets (note when I say perform I mean ‘had more impressions’ because RSA assets don’t perform, the ad unit performs).”
- Watch for case inconsistencies: “All title case human written assets vs sentence-style assets – but again you can remove.”
Language expansion.
ACA for responsive search ads was rolled out in September for general availability in eight languages:
- Dutch
- English
- French
- German
- Italian
- Japanese
- Portuguese
- Spanish
Deep dive.
Watch Google’s quick video tutorial on automatically created assets for more information or read Google’s responsive search ad guide for best practices on creating responsive search ads.
Please rate this post
With over 20 years of experience in the car business, I’ve navigated the evolution of the industry from traditional sales to the dynamic digital age. My journey through various roles in both sales and management has endowed me with a unique perspective on the challenges and opportunities in automotive sales today.
As the founder of Shawn Ryder Digital, I combine my extensive background in technology with my deep understanding of the automotive industry. This synergy allows me to craft digital marketing strategies that are not just effective but tailored to the specific needs of each dealership. My commitment is to drive your sales, enhance your brand awareness, and ensure your dealership thrives in the digital landscape.
Here at Shawn Ryder Digital, we’re not just about providing services; we’re about building partnerships. As I often say, “In the fast-paced world of digital marketing, staying ahead isn’t just an option; it’s a necessity.”
Together, let’s embrace the challenges of the digital age and turn them into opportunities for growth and success. Join me in redefining the future of automotive digital marketing. Let’s accelerate your dealership’s journey to the top.